Tuesday, October 7, 2014

All Together Now! Everybody!

(Read Part One of this post here)

If there is one thing that stood out at the people's climate march was just how many agendas, viewpoints, causes and spiritual convictions, it channelled together. There was, of course, the criticism that the march did not have a single clear message, that there was no list of demands, no universal agenda. That the blame was not placed directly enough, that the tone was too jubilant, and not serious enough or forceful. But I feel like those commentators sort of missed the point.

The groups and individuals organizing the march are trying to build a movement, to bring together a number converging groups, from very different backgrounds around the single issue that effects everyone. The very idea that groups like labour, indigenous rights, student rights, veterans against wars for oil, people for wind energy and people against fracking, should have somehow sat together for months, possibly years, to draft a detailed agenda of everything we demand, is slightly ludicrous. It also exhibits the old kind of activist thinking, in which that our interests don't intersect. That divestment means job loss. That Christian groups can't be in agreement with the LGBTQ-folks. That undocumented immigrants are at odds with labor activists. That those marching for sustainable agriculture, won't march next to animal rights activists.

The march was, as had been said time and time again, a way to unite people who have been working on different sides of the same issue and to show others, peripherally concerned, that there is a movement for them, for all of us to join in. That's all. It was a call to action, not just to our complacent leaders, but to all of us; designed so that anyone who has been worrying about climate change could sound it, not just folks in the margins, not just hardcore activists, but families, small-town grandparents, elementary school classes, metro bus drivers, scientists and retired air force colonels.

There was a tacit agreement that for now we march and rejoice and gather our strength and then, we are going to discuss the particulars, but also get to work in our respective fields of interest, armed with the knowledge that others, elsewhere are working towards the same goals from a different angle. That you can build a movement from seemingly disparate pieces and you have to start somewhere.

As Naomi Klein put it at the end of her speech at the closing plenary of the Climate Convergence, her voice breaking even as she was leading up to it, speaking of the long road that many activists have traveled to get to this point:

"This time we're maybe saying: do something. Next time we say: Now we want everything!"

So what does this mean from the smaller, more personal perspective? What kind of action can we all take in our own lives to help battle global climate change? Those of us ready to act, ready to march, may be looking to the next big action, the next big shift, and hopefully as this movement builds up those will keep coming, but even more important is the work that we do in our own communities and in our personal lives every day.

Here's a completely non-comprehensive list of "climate hacks" emotional, spiritual, practical and communal. Many of them are simply examples, so don't get too hung up on the particulars. They're tried and true tricks, some I personally do often, or will do more now in order to continue to stay connected to the larger framework of this movement. Feel free to add to the list in the comments, and tell your stories of actions, big and small that you've taken, or continue to take.

The Basics:

1. First, assess your level involvement and your level of satisfaction with that involvement. The way our lives currently unfold in this particular paradigm (or whatever paradigm you happen to live in), the systemic and endemic problems we face actually make it really hard for us to be active. So be like a good teacher with yourself: kind and gentle, yet firm. Start small, but be honest.

Already spend three hours a month writing to your congress person? That's great. Add another hour and invite a friend to join you. Don't spend a single hour a month writing to your congress person? Try it out for one letter. Never been to a protest? This could be your chance. Been to plenty of protests? Give organizing a try. The possibilities of involvement are literally endless and multifaceted. But you do have to figure out what you can do and what fits into your life with a little squeezing.

This is something that will ebb and flow, but of course, as we become more involved, our involvement will in turn grow, in a sort snowball kind of way. Just remember, be kind to yourself. Exponential growth is a myth.

2.Get informed. Arm yourself with facts. Whether or not this is information that you've been avoiding, or something that you peripherally know, now is the time to peek under the bed and face the monster. Read up on the basics of global climate change and the science. Then find out how it's effecting your country, state, county, and town.

I'm generally not a fan of buying books (or anything else for that matter) new, but if you can, I actually really recommend buying and reading This Changes Everything right now, in the expensive hardback copy (unless of course you win it from me;). Why? Because that'll help keep it on the bestseller lists and that way even more people will become, interested and possibly even informed. Another really good one, is Field Notes From a CatastropheListen to alternative news podcasts while you do chores. Set your browser homepage to a newspaper that actually talks about climate change. Don't get overwhelmed by facts, but do try to gain an understanding how scientists and other experts think that things are going to unfold.

Hard as facing and accepting these fact will be, it will also help strengthen your resolve to act. It will also enable you to help inform others and not get flustered when your republican cousin starts filibustering about it at Thanksgiving.

3. Find your angle. Are you a feminist? Find out how climate change ties into women's rights. Are you parent? Find out how you can better your children's future. A nature lover? Find out what warming temperatures, or irregular weather patterns will do to your bio-region. Religious? Does your church do relief work related to the issue? Have your religious leaders addressed it? Did you vote in the last election? What is your elected representative doing about this topic? (Even if you were unable to vote, you are still a constituent of your district's representative.)

No one is asking you to know everything about all the issues, let alone deal with them all, but you are asked to view your involvement in a wider context. Finding your way into the climate movement through your existing priorities, can be simpler and more comfortable than plugging into something completely unfamiliar.

4. Be local. It's not just about eating local, buying local, using local services and supporting local small businesses, which reduces your carbon footprint and supports the resilience and self-sufficiency of your area, but it 's also about knowing where you live. In a globalized world we all move around a lot, shaking regional identities often enough to not really familiarize ourselves with them. This can make us complacent about the impact we're having on places. It can make us blissfully ignorant about shifts in patterns, or the disappearance of native species.

Learn to know the history of your area, so as to understand the conflicts that climate action may face there, learn your about the plants and fauna of your immediate surrounding area, as well as your bio-region, learn about the indigenous people who may have been displaced from that area.

Work at becoming a native species. Even if you're just passing through. This will not just help you connect what is happening in your neighborhood to the wider issues of climate change, it will also improve your quality of life. I promise. Find out what your local climate-related issues are. Coal plants, coal trains, big ag, fracking, processing plants, mining, and so on, but also really more seemingly innocuous stuff like habitat loss, almost unnoticeable native species in danger. This will help give you focus and something close to home to be outraged by.

Find positive local solutions. Find out about local conservation efforts, find out about where and how your household waste and waste water is dealt with, find out how your power company works and whether it can be turned into a co-op and whether that co-op can invest in renewables…

Get spiritual, political and…gasp! maybe even radical…:

1. Don't fall pray to magical thinking. Once you've done your research, you'll know that the odds are good that no guru, no miracle energy source, no effortless paradigm shift from the sheer power of positive thinking is going to save our assess. As much as I would LOVE to be proven wrong on any of these accounts, I think that it is important that we act as though we had no other choice.

2. Build Community. So you don't have an awesome posse of like-minded activist friends. Me neither. Find groups in your area that are into what you're into. Locate your local 350 chapter and find out about actions and events. Maybe you'll make new activist friends. But better yet: turn your old friends into new activist friends. Ask a friend to go to a meeting with you, or participate in a letter-writing campaign over a bottle of wine, or at least some delicious teas. You can spend quality time together, all the while you seal envelopes. Select a thought-provoking book for your book club. Get your PTA to do an Earth Day action. If you can't find a group you can join, start one and invite friends and family. You may find  you're more like-minded on the topic than you thought. Maybe someone just needed to bring the issue to the surface.

Have solidarity. Stay informed on the what's going on with the rest of the movement and connect with people working on the same issues you are, whether they're in the next county over, or in Papua New Guinea. Make sure that your community of activists connects with others near and far. Learn about indigenous struggles, challenges of other continents, the issues people of other socioeconomic niches and ethnic backgrounds are dealing with around this single, bigger problem. There's no better way to get ideas and learn new things.  Come out to support others who are not in your immediate interest group when they need you. You may make internets friends. Or real life allies.

3. Demand your elected leaders to represent you. I know letter-writing sounds like listening to Bob Dylan on an 8-track, while wearing polyester bell-bottoms, but there's a reason why it's an activist staple. Regardless of the big money the corporations use to buy elections, your elected official still needs you to vote for them come election season. This is all the more true the more local the election. Even if your chosen representative didn't win, the guy who holds the seat still represents you. And if you did vote for them what they do reflects directly on you.

Write. Be polite, articulate and firm, but also authentic. Your representative probably gets plenty of form-letters, but not as many heartfelt pleas, possibly with photos, or hand-drawn cards made by the smallest of constituents, or typewritten notes explaining to them that should they fail to act, your PTA, clean-air advocacy, book club, or witch's coven is going to storm City Hall. Which BTW, you can fight.

Speaking of hand-written notes from kids. Get your kids involved. Have them think of something they care about and write to their representative about it. In my experience children can really benefit from early exposure to the idea that they have a say.

ps. Don't be a slacktivist. Posting endless online petitions and articles on social media, is not enough of an action to feel good about. If you do it, back it up with something that involves actual thought and care and even lifting your booty off the chair.

4. Demand that your religious leaders stick to their moral commitments. Same thing. If your Buddhist Temple owns stock in big oil, it's your duty to point out that this is multiple steps off the Eight-Fold Path.

5. Show up. Find out about meetings, be they the city council, your neighborhood, or the zoning board, relating to climate issues and try to be there. Bring your elders, bring your friends, bring your kids.

Show solidarity with other groups by going to rallies for them. Don't be a nimbyist. Have a "not here or anywhere" policy. If you're not okay with a coal plant in your neighborhood, you shouldn't be okay with it in another neighborhood across town.

Hopefully we'll all get plenty more marching experience, with actions across the country. Find out what folks are marching for near you.

6. Demand answers from companies you buy from. If every mom in America wrote a letter to whatever retailer they buy their kid's clothes from, every time they do it, detailing how much more they would be willing to pay for said clothes if they were a) fairly made b) environmentally sound c) more durable, I'm pretty sure they would pay attention. If you're frustrated with the lack of both affordable and ethical options in the consumer goods you buy, let the companies know. They have 1800-numbers.

7. Schedule action time and keep up on what you care about. I try to take a few evenings a month when instead surfing around the internet aimlessly, I catch up on issues I care about and write those letters, or find out about actions to take, or local issues.  This way you'll never miss a historic moment. Or a zoning board meeting.

8. If When, disaster strikes, make sure to connect the dots. Watching the news can be terrifying. But when typhoons hit, or your home state burns, it's good to first help organize relief and then figure out the how these disasters connect to big business, big oil, our own wasteful lifestyles. As these events become more and more common, we need to not become complacent, or accepting of them, but rather try to root out the causes and call out the guilty parties.

Big events have big potential, both for paralyzing people with fear and despair and for catalyzing otherwise busy and/or complacent folks into action.

9. Be in nature. It's easier to fight for the one you know and love.

Be with animals. I don't mean majestic elk, or wolves, or whale watching. I mean, observe and acknowledge animal life around you. Saving the birds, the bugs and the tadpoles, from shrinking habitats, to changing migration markers, should be part of all of our mission. It's not just about people, people.

10. Speaking of which, Keep a Nature Journal. If you jot down your observations about the changing of the seasons, the migrations of birds, the appearance of bugs, the temperatures, the rainfalls, the fire seasons, the berry ripenings, patterns will begin to appear. A great activity for little humans.

11. Acknowledge compromise. Acknowledge that your trip to New York city generates carbon, acknowledge that you're driving too much, acknowledge Madewell-brand cotton shirts waste water in areas of the world already effected by water-loss from climate change, acknowledge that cheap meat is an all-around climate disaster, acknowledge that consumer goods and food imports have a huge carbon footprint…

Don't get overwhelmed and depressed, but try to acknowledge it when you compromise, because that acknowledgement is the final check on the necessity of that compromise. Some compromises can't be helped, but others can not be made, or at least not made again, if we stop thinking of them as "normal", things to do.

12. Make it fun. I know that acknowledging every climate compromise you make sounds more like an endless parade of self-flagellation, but it can also make you appreciate abundance instead of bemoaning too much choice, or help you re-find the wonder flying, or an appreciation for new shoes, or the magic of digital devices.

Be creative in your activism, use it to meet people, feel empowered, discover hidden talents you didn't even know you possessed (Who knew you were great at community organizing?!!). Celebrate your victories, however small. Learn about places and cultures and people and species you didn't even know you were connected...

Celebrate the season, do certain things at certain times of the year. Gather food and medicine and make preserves and teas.  The possibilities for fun really are endless.

13. Be loud and proud. Don't be a closeted environmentalist. Don't be intimidated by labels. Like nature, or the Earth? Don't want it to go to the pits? Are willing to do something about it? You're an environmentalist.

Practical tips:

Maybe you already know of all of these things, but the bottom-line with making personal choices against climate change, is that no matter what the future holds, we're all probably going to be forced to do with at least a little less. Less choice, less material goods, less disposable income, less security, less abundance. If we make some of those choices willingly now, we may collectively be able to avert being forced to make them later.

I'm not going to list all the myriad of ways that we can all consume less and release less greenhouse gases, simply because that could take all night day week. But I am going to talk a little bit about ways to address and mitigate one's impact, both simple and complex. Many of these are just examples, so don't get too hung up on them and please add your own tips and thoughts in the comments.

1. Be local. I know I already said this but eating locally and seasonally is as environmentally sound as it gets. It's an everyday action anyone can participate in. I know there are some limitations to this, but as a basic statement of where we should be putting our dollars, this one is pretty sound.

Also, if you can't afford it, or feel like local organic is elitist, a great way to help with that is to start an organic food pantry, a farm food bank, or help make sure your closest farmer's market takes food stamps.  If you happen to grow your own produce, consider growing a little extra for your local food bank.

Growing your own is great, but if that is not an option for one reason or another, getting your basic groceries as local, seasonal and organic as possible is a grand start.

2. Make your own, borrow and buy used. I know. I know. Vintage, DIY movement, makers, blah blah blah… but to be totally honest, one of the easiest ways to safe money and add more satisfaction to your life, is the create your own versions of the consumer goods you're forced to spend your hard earned dollars on. Make your own cleaning supplies, or bake your own bread, knit your own socks, or simply help your kids create toys, all of these actions are good for both you and the planet.

As for used items, more often than not, we all know someone who already has it, if you can't take whatever it is home for the night, or over the weekend and then return it, I bet it's at your nearest thrift store, or maybe on craigslist.

3. Get organized and share resources. Don't have enough time, or resources to devote to your favorite cause, or even making apple sauce?

Find ways to share the workload with others who feel the same and want to do the same things, whether it's car-pooling, or neighborhood childcare, canning, or broth making,  anything that saves you on travel time and gasoline, is probably good for everyone, the environment included. You can achieve things you dream off, like driving less, or having a garden by finding others with similar goals. Share tools of for preservation, for yard work, share books, share magazine subscriptions, share clothes, share babysitters. Share resources.

Each one teach one. Don't be afraid to ask for help, if you want to do something, but don't know how. Don't be afraid to share your expertise on a particular topic with those who might need more help with it.

Prioritize the things that really matter and try to get more of them by organizing and less of that which depletes you and warms the planet. Make a meal plan, so that you don't have to drive to the grocery store as often. Plan a family fun day, or a date, at home, or in your neighborhood rather than driving to some attraction somewhere else and spending half the day in a car. The possibilities are endless.

4. Eat less meat and fly less. For the longest time when folks did talk about climate change, they would often lament that there was no action they could personally take. Then when we found out that there was a couple of things, most everyone balked at them.

When it comes to meat, or animal protein in general, it's really important to finally read all those awful things about the impacts of factory farming on the environment, the animals and our own health. Then not eating much meat won't be much of stretch at all. Do yourself a favor. Get convinced before you watch any of those videos.

5. Conserve. Make a point of conserving, as a family or with a group of friends. Schedule a car-free day once a week. If you already have one, schedule another one. This is will also help to appreciate the rides you do go on and mitigate their impact. Turn off the lights, the computers and the televisions for a night. I'd leave the fridge and the freezer on. But candle light ghost stories, or star gazing, or heck, light pollution gazing can be pretty fun.

Even if you want to keep the lights on, consider and unplugging month, where you try to save as much electricity as possible, by unplugging devices that aren't being used and turning off the ones that usually always stay on. Figure out if makes a difference in your power bill (I'm so doing this, as the nights get longer here, we use so much more kilowatts).

6. Act on local concerns. Live in California? Put a bucket in your shower during the dry season and flush your toilet with the water. Live in Paris? Use public transportation and demand the city council make it affordable. Live in Florida? Make sure you've got your storm kit and make doubly sure that your city has its too. Live anywhere in Canada? Make a "fuck harper"-T-shirt. Just kidding.

7. Divest. Lucky enough to have some stocks from Grandma? Make sure they're not in big oil. Have a pension fund? In college? Make sure your money is not being spent on destroying your future.

8. Speaking of money. Can't afford to financially support you favorite causes? Learn to pinch pennies from surprising sources. Also, if you get organized and make adjustments to your plans, or start making more things instead of buying them, keep a tally of whether you're saving any money. Things like not driving as much, cooking more simply, or simply refraining from buying things, can add up pretty quickly (Definitely something I'm planning to work on this coming season.)

9.  Doubt everything. If you're not sure whether your choice in political candidate, sweatshirt, brand of cereal is in line with your values, it's probably not. Don't assume that things are what they seem. This could also be worded another way: think for yourself. Do research. Check the facts.

Now what do you think we ought to do to keep this momentum going?

And remember: every comment has a chance at winning a copy of Naomi Klein's  This Changes Everything and comment is free!

I'm sorry I didn't get this post up last night like I promised. I could have sworn I had it scheduled, but it was not meant to be.


  1. Such wonderful, creative &inspirational people! So glad you shared this!

  2. Another great post! I find unplugging things makes a real difference. I used to leave my internet modem, laptop, toaster, etc plugged in all day even though I wasn't home and then all night while I slept! Even if it doesn't save me money on my power bill it is certainly less wasteful.

    PS. LOVE the fuck Harper T-shirt! However, fellow canadians, forget the t-shirt and for the love of god just don't vote for him again!

  3. Wonderful post, Milla. Meatless Monday, et al will help if everyone joins in. I'm boycotting all the Koch brothers products - Georgia Pacific brands to be specific. Evil men and I never knew they were making money off of so many products and us.

  4. Love these posts!I really liked your story from the march and am feeling very inspired by the second post. My next step will be finding some likeminded people to campaign with.

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    1. More biking and letter writing, more local & homegrown produce, and trying to attend more local climate & environmental activism events for me! Also here's an article you might find interesting about my old/now new state:
      http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/10/02/magazine/mag-oil-lawsuit.html Largely about the lawsuit and legislative shenanigans [and: positive progress!
      but also really shocking and stunning visuals.

  6. Mieletön energia välittyy kyllä hyvin tekstistäsi ja kuvistasi. Mahtavaa!
    Mulle tekee niin hyvää nähdä tuo massa ihmisiä marssimassa itselleni tärkeän asian puolesta.
    Täällä nenä jo kiinni ko.kirjassa:-)

  7. These last two posts were inspiring and informative! Unfortunately my comment on your last post got deleted but oh well. One thing I said in it which I got a glimpse of through your pictures was the amazing energy there. I'm sure it was exhilarating! I'm thankful for you words because they coincide with many of my thoughts I've had recently. Running a house with as many people as we have in ours is a big opportunity to either be very wasteful or really tighten things up and be conservative. Knowing that there are so many small things I can do is very reassuring for me. I'll definitely be pondering your words as move forward with my day. Love you!

  8. Again Milla, this is tremendously inspiring, but also very useful - you really researched so many possibilities! It's a good idea to acknowledge our compromises along with what we are already doing. I've begun a list of both in various fields...

    I find also helpful to set up our priorities - things we find so important that we need to find solutions for maintaining them in our lifestyle, or for establishing new habits in accordance to these priorities.

    For instance, buying only *organic eggs and yogurt* is an absolute rule for me, even when I can't afford organic vegetables. Lentils, black beans or (organic) tofu are surprisingly affordable compared to meat, by the way. And of course much more gentle for our planet.

    Since my whole family lives in France, the issue of flying is a very real one for me. I am slowly getting used to the idea of flying back there only every two years (thank you Skype!) while having a very low carbon footprint at home, whether on transportation (hello biking!), heating (hello pretty icelandic sweaters!) and electricity (I bake everything at once).

    My weak point is certainly being active within my community! So thanks for your various suggestions, Milla :o)


  9. If I post twice sorry. I think my first attempt just went poof though.

    I will start making time to write letters once a month - if everyone in my state did, maybe I wouldn't feel like my voice doesn't get heard here in Texas.

    I definitely need to find the community. I never find out about things enough ahead of time to make the time to do them.

    The last few weeks I have been greening up my life; a little involuntarily... my marriage broke up, so now I am trying to learn to cook for myself; he used to do all the cooking. I am going with fresh stuff, trying to eat vegetarian at least one day a week, and have been gratified at how much less trash that produces. I think I will check out my local farmer's market tomorrow morning.

  10. I'm really excited about thinking about small, meaningful changes. I keep thinking about the fact that I want to be on the right side of history, and I can't count on other people to do what I know I need to be doing myself.

  11. Thank you Milla for your involvement in this issue and your ideas for a way forward.

    My own ‘hacking’ the climate crisis has mostly revolved around 2.) Get Informed and 9.) Doubt Everything. I started out two years ago when I learned that a major solar power plant in the California desert is (needlessly) destroying intact, beautiful, thriving habitat for endangered Desert Tortoises. My reaction was "What? I thought solar power is good!" This bit of awareness rapidly led to learning about the politics of renewable energy siting, which led me to the learning about the energy grid in the western US, which led me to the “upstream” costs of renewables, which led to questioning corporate investment in green tech, which led to the pitfalls of supporting foundation-sponsored environmental organizations, which led to… and so on, down one endless rabbit-hole after another.

    The upshot of all this research and reading has mostly been a nagging headache and the need for fresh air—but also the knowledge that most of the people I talk to (including the authors of many of the blogs I follow) are frighteningly uninformed as to the true nature of our predicament.

    As moving as the NYC climate march was, I see the danger of believing in such mass marches as a tool for deep transformation. Because while slogans can motivate, slogans can also mask the true depth of problems and lull people into a false sense of hope. For example, “Leave it in the Ground!” presents the idea that we can voluntarily stop using fossil fuel reserves and turn instead to some other forms of energy to power our modern civilization. I won’t even begin to unpack that issue, except to say that it’s a highly misleading (if not downright false) idea. As a slogan, it feels good to say, and it raises our hopes that such a thing might be true; but as a strategy for change, it falls precipitously short.

    I think that mass marches are effective tools for public awareness, but I do not hold out too much faith that they will shake the power structures to the degree necessary for real change. My heart goes out to those who do hold this faith: I hope you are right.

    Milla, I hope that I don’t sound as though I disagree with the substance of your post. I think that for most people, the ideas herein are good models to live by. For them, knowing the big picture would be too frightening, too devastating to acknowledge, especially those who have (or wish to have) children. If I had kids I doubt I would be on the journey I am now, as it seems that having children requires a belief that you can offer them a future that is a least as bright as today.
    That bright future is in no way assured. We who live in the developed world have, by and large, no capacity to fathom the amount of energy and resources that are required to create this comfortable world. Even lives of voluntary simplicity, as manifested by many in our community, still rely upon a massive Machine that consumes entire ecosystems to keep itself alive.
    So here is one radical, and many will say heretical, bit of unsolicited advice: fly more. If you have ever wanted to see Angor Wat, or the Hagia Sophia, or the Amazon rain forest, or Yellowstone, go now. If you have loved ones in far-flung places, go see them now. Dreams of flight have haunted us since the first spark of human consciousness; only a few generations of humans have enjoyed this miracle come true. Air travel will be the first major casualty of a decarbonizing society: there is no alternative to oil-powered airplanes in our lifetimes, and maybe not for many centuries or millennia to come. So go, and see our beautiful and flawed world.

    Soon, our lives will be more local, by choice for some, but for most by necessity. But it is good to learn how to be local; it is, after all, how we lived before fossil fuels, and it will be how we will live after we have spent our inheritance of carbon, this gift of the deep Earth.